It used to be that a 1-star review was a cry for help. A customer would write a paragraph detailing their frustration: “The box arrived crushed” or “They sent the wrong color.” While painful, this text was valuable. It told you what to fix. More importantly, it gave you the ammunition to appeal. With the full rollout of Star-Only Seller Feedback in late 2025, Amazon has silenced the customer—and handcuffed the seller.
Contents
The Mechanics of the Update
Amazon wants more ratings. To get them, they removed the friction of writing. Now, a buyer simply taps the 1-star icon and moves on with their day.
- The Benefit: You will likely see more 5-star ratings from happy, lazy customers.
- The Cost: You will see a spike in 1-star ratings from unhappy, lazy customers.
The “Appeal” Problem
Here is the policy detail that matters:
The “Request Removal” button is ineffective for star-only ratings.
Amazon’s logic is simple: If there is no text, they cannot verify if the rating violates policy.
- Was it a product review (which shouldn’t be on Seller Feedback)? Unknown.
- Was it a delivery delay (which is Amazon’s fault)? Unknown.
- Was it abusive? Unknown. Because it is unknown, it stays.
The “FBA Strike-Through” Era is Over
The most common way sellers maintained a 100% rating was by striking through feedback related to FBA fulfillment. If a customer leaves a silent 1-star because their Prime delivery was late, you take the blame. Your metrics degrade because of Amazon’s logistics failure, and you have no mechanism to prove it.
Your Defense Strategy (The Big Internet Ecommerce Method)
Since you can’t fight the rating, you must fight the friction.
-
The “Pre-Rating” Intercept
You must optimize your Buyer-Seller Messaging templates. When a customer initiates a return, your auto-response must be immediate, empathetic, and solution-oriented. You need to resolve the emotion before Amazon prompts them to rate the transaction.
-
The “Report Abuse” Backdoor
While the standard appeal is dead, the “Report Abuse” link still functions. BIE’s Account Health specialists use this channel for our clients. We monitor for patterns (e.g., 5 silent 1-star ratings in an hour) that indicate a bot attack. We present this data to Amazon’s executive seller teams to get removals based on behavioral anomalies rather than text content.
-
Packaging as Insurance
If the customer receives a beat-up brown box, they click 1-star. If they receive a branded, premium unboxing experience, they might still return it, but they are statistically less likely to leave a hateful silent rating. Packaging is your new reputation insurance.
Silence isn’t golden. It’s dangerous. Let BigIntermetEcommerce help you navigate the noise.
Book a call to get your customized strategy roadmap today.
Follow Big Internet Ecommerce (BIE) on Instagram & LinkedIn to stay updated with the latest trends in Amazon selling.
